No one is entitled to bail, even powerful or influential individuals, such as prominent rapper and producer Sean “Diddy” Combs, who was recently denied bail twice after being indicted on multiple federal charges for sexual abuse and other offenses in September 2024.
In fact, being influential and having access to considerable resources could negatively affect defendants regarding bail, which happened in Combs’ case. When rejecting his multiple bail requests, the court expressed its opinion that Combs was a flight risk and posed a danger to the community if he were to be released for the duration of his criminal trial, despite him surrendering his passport and agreeing to ankle monitoring. The potential threat of witness tampering in a case that heavily relies on witnesses to feel safe and comfortable to testify was another factor in the court’s decision to deny bail, one that often affects criminal defendants facing trial.
Call Overson Law, PLLC today at (801) 758-2287 for a free and confidential case assessment from our Utah criminal defense lawyers.
Why Diddy Was Denied Bail, and Why No One Is Entitled to It
While there are bail guidelines judges follow, amounts are largely left up to a judge’s discretion. They can deny bail altogether to respect the nature of the alleged crimes, because the defendant is a flight risk, and or out of concern for witness tampering, all of which were reasons Combs was repeatedly denied bail after being charged with multiple felony offenses concerning a sex trafficking and abuse conspiracy which he, according to the federal indictment, was in charge of.
The Nature of the Alleged Crimes
Those facing serious charges might be denied bail out of concern for the general public’s safety. This is one of the reasons why the court denied Combs bail initially, as he is charged with leading a conspiracy that engaged in kidnapping, sex trafficking, bribery, forced labor, and other serious crimes. The indictment alleges that Combs also personally abused women over many years, and the court agreed his release from prison would endanger the general public. The indictment contains shocking details of Diddy’s alleged crimes, detailing how the prominent producer and co-conspirators treated victims, allegedly drugging and sexually assaulting them, sometimes over the course of several days at a time. If convicted, Combs could face multiple life sentences, illustrating the severity of the crimes he is charged with. Even for criminal offenses less serious than those Combs is facing, judges might deny or revoke bail if defendants routinely miss court dates or are disruptive in court.
The number of charges against a defendant could also lead to high or no bail. Diddy is charged with multiple felony counts, all concerning an alleged racketeering conspiracy that engaged in sex trafficking and violence and affected many victims over many years, making him ineligible for jail in the judge’s eyes.
The Defendant is a Flight Risk
Judges consider various factors when evaluating if a defendant is a flight risk. For example, suppose a defendant has considerable financial resources and faces serious federal offenses, as in Combs’ situation. In that case, the court might decide they are a likely risk to flee and deny bail altogether. Sometimes, defendants may get bail after surrendering their passports or agreeing to ankle monitoring, and Combs’ attorneys preemptively offered these terms before his second bail hearing. In addition, Combs offered up one of his mansions, valued at $48 million, as collateral, as well as his mother’s passport and his children’s passports. Combs was denied bail a second time despite these proposals, likely due to his extraordinary financial resources and connections.
Judges consider a defendant’s financial status when assessing whether or not they are a flight risk, but it is not the only factor involved. For example, defendants with extensive criminal histories or lack of community ties might be considered flight risks. Defendants who demonstrate their ties to the community or their families’ dependence on them may be able to avoid the label of a flight risk despite having criminal histories, particularly if previous convictions are unrelated to or less serious than the current charges they are facing.
Concern for Witness Tampering
Combs is accused of using his position of power in the entertainment industry to perform various acts of sexual violence over many years personally and by leading a conspiracy for that specific purpose. Because witnesses are so vital in the prosecution’s case, the court was concerned that Combs would contact or instruct his associates to contact and attempt to further influence witnesses based on allegations of the defendant previously using blackmail and violence to stop victims from seeking help. This concern contributed to the court’s decision to deny bail at both hearings on the matter. Combs and his attorneys proposed a $50 million bail, limits on visitors, and GPS monitoring in exchange for allowing him to await trial at a home in Florida near Miami Beach. The court denied this proposal, mandating Combs remain imprisoned throughout his criminal case.
When criminal cases rely heavily on witness testimony, and those witnesses are alleged victims of violent acts like sexual abuse or assault, judges might be hesitant to set bail, especially when criminal defendants have access to substantial resources, as in Sean Combs’ case.
The Defendant’s Criminal History
Judges typically weigh a defendant’s criminal history when considering whether or not to set bail. Combs has not been convicted of a serious violent crime in the past, though he has faced multiple civil lawsuits for sexual assault and abuse. A criminal record could indicate to a judge that a defendant will likely re-offend while on bail. Especially if a defendant’s criminal record concerns violent crimes, judges might refuse to set bail to protect the public.
Call Our Lawyers for Help with Your Case Today
Call Overson Law, PLLC today at (801) 758-2287 for help with your case from our Park City, UT criminal defense lawyers.
